Thursday, June 6, 2013

Scottish Independence: Scotland’s unpopular Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon says Scots MPs are ‘outvoted in UK’, her ideas on democracy appear to be ‘its okay as long as you are in power’, now she is ‘standing up for Labour’!

Dear All

It seems that Scotland’s unpopular Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has decided to ‘stand up for Labour’.

Her latest pitch of angry Nationalism centres around the fact that Scottish MPs continue to be outvoted on issues affecting everyday life in Scotland.

Scotland doesn’t have the same number of MPs as England; her argument is therefore in part a numbers game.

Apparently the years when there is a Labour Government and Scottish MPs vote along Government lines don’t matter.

Sturgeon says this is one of the “many flaws” of the Westminster system of government.

Democracy is a flaw?

Nicola Sturgeon pointed to 10 policy areas where a majority of MPs representing constituencies in Scotland now have opposed the decisions taken in the House of Commons.

The issues include the recent implementation of the bedroom tax to the invasion of Iraq.

If Labour were in power, down South, and introduced the bedroom tax, these same anti bedroom tax MPs would be voting for it if whipped.

Her ‘democratic case’ for independence is incredibly weak.

Ms Sturgeon said:

“We know that Scottish MPs at Westminster have voted against many key aspects of UK policy. Under the previous Labour UK government, a majority of Scottish MPs voted against Trident renewal and the invasion of Iraq. This year the welfare benefits cap and the bedroom tax were both opposed by 91% of Scottish MPs. This week Scotland’s MPs backed challenging green energy targets, whilst Westminster as a whole voted against”.

She added:

“There are many flaws with the current Westminster system of government. The first-past-the-post electoral system is deeply unrepresentative”.

And as we have seen in newspaper reports, the list system for Holyrood can be rigged; this story might help explain further how that could be done:

As one SNP official said to me, the SNP has the best election system that money can buy.

Presumably she is advocating PR because there is no other way that the SNP would increase Westminster seats unless perhaps there is a total collapse in Lib Dems vote which they might benefit from in the sticks.

She added the power of the House of Lords contradicts basic principles of democracy.

How wrong she is, does she ever watch House of Lords debates, and then she might have caught the recent one on Rehabilitation of Offenders which some on the Lords have openly criticised the UK government for lack of detail on their recent Bill.

To address more of her shit talk; Westminster’s doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty is incompatible with the fundamental principle that, in Scotland, sovereignty rests with the people.

That is just delusional wank.

Sturgeon added:

“Those problems could, in theory, be reformed although there is little sign of that happening. However, the biggest problem with Scotland’s current constitutional position, that majority Scottish opinion on issues that affect our everyday life can always be outvoted, cannot be dealt with through change at Westminster”.

Westminster would be dancing to Holyrood’s tune, the tail doesn’t wag the dog dear

Sturgeon finally rattled out:

“Scotland now faces a choice of two futures. We can continue to make up less than a tenth of the MPs in Parliament whose decisions on welfare, defence and the economy routinely disregard our wishes. Or we can become a truly equal partner through independence.”

Unless there is a Labour Government, apparently Ms. Sturgeon seems to be believes that democracy only can happen if Labour is in power in Westminster.

The ‘cure’ therefore is that the Scottish Tories get elected to more seats in Scotland thus curing the problem for Ms. Sturgeon.

They must be laughing their heads off in Westminster as Nicola Sturgeon ‘stands up for Labour’, democracy works; the people have spoken and they say firmly, keep the SNP out of Westminster in large numbers.

Part time SNP MPs are irrelevant as they continue to be little better than squatters.

Yours sincerely

George Laird
The Campaign for Human Rights at Glasgow University

No comments: