Friday, March 2, 2012

Business chiefs want Alex Salmond to hold an early Scottish independence referendum, FM can’t do that, as his SNP activist base desert him













Dear All

With the referendum pencilled in by the Scottish Government for autumn of 2014, some people are confused by the date.

Recently the new Sun on Sunday paper was launched by Rupert Murdoch which gave the date as 18TH October 2014.

The paper felt so confident that it published this date after speaking to SNP sources, while there is a ‘consultation’ going on.

Is 18TH October 2014, a credible date?

Well what are happening in 2014?

Commonwealth Games and other high profile events are taking place that the First Minister Alex Salmond and his Cabinet will attend to get exposure by piggy backing on them as part of their strategy to convince people to vote for independence.

And if any Scots win then the photo op comes naturally after that, basking in others popularity is a standard PR tactic.

However, not everyone wishes to wait such a long time for the referendum to take place with engineering leaders adding to the growing calls from business for a speedy referendum on independence.

They argue that uncertainty could undermine business.

This argument seems to me to be weak, and it is unlikely that the SNP will bring forward their referendum.

Quite simply Alex Salmond has no one to work for him.

And even loyal activists are deserting him.

Peter Hughes, chief executive of Scottish Engineering, said the "vast majority" of his members wanted the vote to be held before autumn 2014.

This kind of echos what Michael Moore said a few weeks ago that 2013 should be used as the date, unfortunately the SNP are physically unable to bring their plans forward having set branches too many tasks without having the skills base to action them.

Hughes says a survey of members of the group indicated only 22% were happy with the 2014 date.

74% want the referendum to be held "much earlier".

That won’t happen, Alex Salmond isn’t a listening leader, given my personal experience; he will stick to 2014.

However, I don’t think 18th October is the right date; he sticks a referendum at the ‘end of the party’ season regarding events, when he should stick it in the middle two weeks after the Commonwealth Games to take advantage of the party atmosphere.


Mr Hughes also highlight what is developing as a theme in Scotland, he calls on SNP politicians to answer key questions on independence.

Typically Hughes's comments were welcomed by Scottish Secretary Michael Moore, who said business was making its voice heard "loud and clear".

Moore added that there was an "undeniable head of steam" building up, stating:

"Let's get on with asking the Scottish people a single question next year."

Unionist parties and others are now getting together to put the case for the union to continue, we will see more calls for an early referendum.

Labour leader Ed Miliband is in Dundee today to tell the Scottish Labour conference in Dundee that Scotland and England would be weaker apart, saying:

"If we are going to build an economy that works for working people, we are going to have to build it together."

In football, people like to play a game called ‘keepy up’ where a ball is continually kicked in the air, unfortunately the referendum isn’t a ball and the SNP trying to keep it in the public domain all the time won’t serve their purpose.

Already, the new kid on the block is ‘devo plus’ which opposition parties are gathering round.

One thing is certain, the devo plus option has merit, and if it is delivered by unionist parties, gets on the ballot paper, and independence vote is defeated, the SNP won’t be able to claim they delivered for Scotland.

It will be Westminster.

Then there will be Westminster election to follow and I don’t expect the SNP to do any better than they previously did in 2010, because the SNP is a party only fixate on Holyrood.

They don’t connect with the public on reserve issues, they just don’t connect at all, and you need more than a little ‘Scotlander’ mentality at Westminster, that’s the ‘big hoose’, you need to walk tall there with big ideas and vision.

Yours sincerely

George Laird
The Campaign for Human Rights at Glasgow University

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

You are a prick no wonder no one comments on your stupid fucking blog no one cares what you think

George Laird said...

Dear Anon

You do seem sore and upset about something, have you been a victim of an SNP smear campaign like me?

As to commenting by others, if people wish to comment they can, last month circa 8,000 people stopped by and this is without me advertising.

Also I don't put adverts on my blog which is another way to increase traffic or do any of the other methods used.

I can afford to lose you because I really don't care for the small minded type of nationalist you represent.

Maybe one day the Scottish National Party will subject you to the same type of disgusting treatment they did me, then when you complint to Alex Salmond, you can sit back and watch him do nothing.

A truly noble leader.

Yours sincerely

George Laird

ps make sure on any complaint you tell him you are upper middle class, that way action will get taken.

Anonymous said...

But George, how credible would UKIP be if it was in a position to offer a referendum on EU membership and decided to settle for repatriation of some powers? Alec heads a party with a core mission to deliver independence. That may not be in the best interest of Scotland, but he cannot say that. So if we have a vote and he wins then good. If he has a vote and comes second, also good so long as everything except defence and foreign policy is delivered to Holyrood.

2014 is a good date because it leaves room to recover in time for the elections afterwards - and Labour are so piss poor they most certainly are not in Scotland's interest. It is also significantly the anniversary of Bannockburn.

A date during school holidays is not such a good move. I find much support for the SNP amongst the skilled workers and the modern professionals. They are more likely to be on holiday then and that may dent the vote "For". It also gives the postal vote ballot stuffers more cover. Saturday isnt a good day for a vote either. Sundays would be better because most people don't work then, or stick with the traditional thursday.

I expect the vote to be a narrow lose. Im not sure that doesnt suit AS. So long as the LD's and Tories deliver, then we get the best of both worlds.