Dear All
It seems having been blown off by Westminster in her effort
to get talks, unpopular Nicola Sturgeon is still trying to prove she is
relevant to her supporters, prove she can do ‘something’, she is like someone
with a TV aerial waving it about the place trying to get a picture.
Sturgeon’s latest act is to threaten to torpedo Brexit
legislation, this is much like you feel a stone in your shoe, you stop to
remove then you continue your journey. At present in Scotland ,
the Nationalists are trying to suck people in to believing there is a Westminster "power
grab" about to happen. To that end, the Scottish Greens and Scottish
Labour have joined the party, yet again, by hitching up to the SNP bandwagon;
Scottish Labour has made them irrelevant in the minds of the public.
The problem for Scottish Labour is that they are too inward
looking and not focused on the “bigger picture” because they are entirely
Holyrood focused and based. Effectively, they can write returning to Westminster
for decades the way they are carrying, and given they are polling so badly,
their councillor numbers across Scotland if you believe the polling are about
to take a severe hit.
If there was ever a pressing need for someone in Scottish
Labour to stand up and speak out against the path they are treading, it is
sorely needed now. You almost feel that you want to walk up to some of them and
say, ‘are you fucking stupid, is that your problem’.
Remember this, if there was a Labour Government in power at Westminster , you wouldn’t
be reading about the Scottish Labour Party backing the SNP.
As we have seen devolution isn’t working, the Great Repeal
Bill serves a purpose beyond Brexit, it also offers an opportunity to tailor
select powers for Holyrood. It is entirely right that Westminster should get
all powers repatriated from Brussels to London; then after careful
consideration, decided via a Commission what scope there is to improve
devolution which at present doesn’t work properly.
The SNP Government is inept and incompetent, they want constitutional
clash between the Scottish and UK
governments so they can keep talking about grievance and avoid talking about
devolved issues which they are failing to address. This is a situation where
the SNP need to be forced to do the ‘day job’, online I see people in newspaper
comment sections saying vote independent because these people don’t have to toe
a party line, I see this more and more.
If Nicola Sturgeon wants a fight, then it is time to give
her exactly what she wants, but this time, the rules will be set by Westminster . Westminster needs to start
thinking of the concept that they can step in and overrule Holyrood, and with
the SNP at the helm, this would be the first time since devolution.
Sturgeon’s threat that third rate MSPs might withhold
consent for the Bill, disrupting and delaying the process is a wonderful
opportunity allowing Westminster
scope and with justification to fix Holyrood. We all know in Scotland that
we have a ‘pretend’ parliament which doesn’t work in the interests of Scots,
and hasn’t for about a decade that the SNP have held power. This cannot go on,
my thoughts are when the grievance and complaining starts is to simply ignore
it and press ahead. And make it publicly clear that what is given can be taken
away very easily.
When you look at the state of Scotland , has the SNP created
nirvana in the decade they have held power?
When I read that Nicola Sturgeon was “writing” her letter to
Theresa May on the sofa of Bute House, I laughed, all that time wasted, but what
should the reply be? The reply should be that this matter has been discussed
before and the position of the Prime Minister hasn’t changed. Sturgeon’s letter
for permission to hold a second independence referendum is merely gesture
politics, she has already been told, now is not the time.
This can all be done with a classic one line sentence letter!
Scottish Secretary David Mundell said he thinks the Bill
would mean Holyrood passing a Legislative Consent Motion [LCM], but if they don’t
then it is easy enough to change the law at Westminster . Westminster could in theory they say just
ignore Holyrood and press ahead regardless, but the SNP would seized upon a new
grievance to further its case for independence. Westminster needs to be bold, and if they are
willing to be, they could change the Scotland Act.
The SNP’s game is very obvious; they are ‘in part’ wanting
independence by stealth, this is one of the avenues they are using, so this is why
they have started a fierce dispute over which devolved powers returned from the
EU go to Holyrood after Brexit. Westminster
needs to the SNP powers that they don’t want but are forced as an administration
to use, because you know like the EU farm payments fiasco they will mess it up
down the line.
One of the things which should be carefully thought about is
devolvement of agriculture and fishing so that the UK single market is able to work
properly without any problems. My concern about fishing is the SNP might attempt
to place the industry in a position where the SNP simply let EU fishing boats
into Scottish waters as part of their bid to get fast track EU membership… if
they could ever win a referendum.
The SNP don’t give a monkey’s about the devastating effect
that EU membership had had on the British fishing industry, and that very much
includes the people crewing the Scottish boats. The SNP would sell out anyone
even if it is against the Scottish national interest.
Scottish Labour MP Ian Murray said:
“All repatriated powers in devolved areas that return to the
UK
following Brexit should, in principle, fall under the competency of the
devolved administrations. However, this will be a complex process with a number
of different stages. Both the UK
and Scottish governments have a responsibility to protect the interests of
those affected, including businesses, and our farming and fishing industries.”
Scottish Tory Adam Tomkins said:
“The SNP is complaining about the return of substantial new
powers which - under its plans - would remain in Brussels . If ever people needed to see their
utter hypocrisy, this is it. As the Prime Minister has made crystal clear, the
UK Government expects substantial new powers to be delivered to our devolved
parliaments as a result of Brexit. At the same time, it is sensible to ensure
that UK frameworks are
applied so that, as those powers come back, nothing is done that fragments our
own United Kingdom .
That might be good for the SNP but it would be bad for Scottish jobs.”
At some point, there has to be a fight between Westminster and Holyrood,
whether the Conservatives are willing to do this at this time is debatable, the
Scottish Conservatives being the second party of Holyrood think they have a
shot at being the next government at Holyrood. So, they might not want to ‘rock
the boat’ too much but you know the thing about fighting is that once you start
you don’t stop.
Brexit is going to happen, Nicola Sturgeon’s letter is
meaningless, Scottish Labour need to decide are they a political party or are
they now a just focus group for the SNP, Holyrood will not be allowed to derail
the Brexit process or use new powers to undermine the stability of the UK single
market. The SNP will not be allowed to hold the UK economy as a hostage to fortune.
Finally, did you notice how “happy” Nicola Sturgeon was
writing her poisoned pen letter to Theresa May for a second independence
referendum; it got me thinking of her last gimmick which blew right up in her
face, this one will too, too stupid to learn from her mistakes it seems.
Yours sincerely
George Laird
The Campaign for Human Rights at Glasgow University
My God her sense of entitlement is ridiculous.
ReplyDeleteThanks for another great analysis of the farce which passes for Scottish politics these days George.Just when you thought no one could surpass the woeful ineptitude of the SNP ( I speak as an ex SNP supporter and yes voter ) along comes Scottish Labour to prove you wrong.
ReplyDeleteYou`re right George, the SNP would sell out anyone or any Scottish asset and make a pact with the devil himself in pursuit of their leaders` lust for glory.
Come to think of it, maybe they are not quite as inept as I think and the way they are destroying the once proud Scottish education system is part of a cunning plan to produce Scottish youngsters that are easily brainwashed by the cult and unable to think clearly for themselves. SCOTLAND, wake up to their lies and deceptions before it is too late!
totally agree George, the SNP aren't cutting it with the fake spin, the idea that Nicola Sturgeon just 'wrote' that letter to May on a sofa is sheer nonsense, everything these people do is vetted before seeing the light of day. Remember when the SNP wrote 'Trump's letter' in advance without his knowledge and permission, what a horrible creature Nicola Sturgeon truly is.
ReplyDeleteThe photo released by the SNP of Sturgeon signing her letter to the PM, is a blatent copy of a pose by Margaret Thatcher. I've long thought Sturgeon's protestations about Thatcher and the Tories were always a little too loud. Sturgeon secretly admires and emulates Thatcher, she's no socialist by any stretch of the imagination. After all, Sturgeon only got where she is today thanks to Thatcher's policies, such as the right to buy your council house and getting a free uni education with no student loans. But now Sturgeon has pulled that ladder up behind her and is stopping others from doing the same.
ReplyDeleteThe SNP can't do anything to block or slow down brexit. If their consent isn't forthcoming for legislative changes they will simply be forced upon them. The British parliament is sovereign and supreme - a fact confirmed by the supreme court earlier this year in a unanimous ruling by 11 justices including 2 from Scotland.
ReplyDeletecouldn't have put it better myself George, the wee angry Nat has messed up big style.
ReplyDeleteThe end of Sturgeon is near, I smell it in the wind, too many mistakes and it just will not stop
ReplyDeleteNicola is on the biggest giro in Scotland, why doesn't she get a real job.
ReplyDeleteSay wan thing aboot little miss radio rental, she has stopped workfare in Scotland.Just imagine, no more free labour for fake charity shops n parasites.
ReplyDeleteSo Westminster are "plotting" to grab powers repatriated from Brussels which - according to the SN Me Me Me! should be returned to Holyrood - but presumably Westminster would be expected to "look after them" until such time the Scottish Government is geared up to exercise said powers as they have done with several welfare benefits until 2020. Could the First Minister please advise the people of Scotland precisely which powers She is referring to and which powers would then be transferred straight back to Brussels in the event of an independent Scotland achieving membership of the EU?
ReplyDeletegee wizz 11 comments any mostly from annon thats some reflection of the people's voice .
ReplyDeleteDespite 99.99 % of the media against them the "YES" movement and the SNP have not went away now that must concern people who support this Union , nothing used against the call to be a normal country has worked , oh dear how sad the union is dead live with it
A sizeable minority support independence. But you are pretty far from success and the union is still very much a going concern. Getting over the line will require a great deal of skill and dumb luck. You have no skills and your luck is running out.
DeleteI'm glad Kranky is away to America, we might get a few days peace.
ReplyDeleteOK Mr Laird, you clearly don't like the government and are very good at slagging off Ms Sturgeon. So I challenge you to make the positive case. If She isn't your choice for FM then who, out of the realistic choices available, do you think would do the best job, and why?
ReplyDeleteA lot of mindless turkeys on this site. Thankfully as an Engineer I never went to the Art School in the west end. 62% think that wastemonster should not block the scottish government. Wake up you arty farty types get a real job, like pushing a broom down the road.
ReplyDeleteAbout 70% think we should bring back the rope for murderers. No sign of that returning.
DeleteNewsflash - the people can't always get what they want. We have a system, a constitution, and rule of law. The British parliament determines important issues like the potential break up of the state - not the jumped up toon cooncil in Edinburgh.
You mean the petition signed by people im Afghanistan Bangladesh Brazil ect ect aye rite ya prick
ReplyDeleteYou mean the petition signed by people im Afghanistan Bangladesh Brazil ect ect aye rite ya prick
ReplyDeleteThis article reads like it was written by a child.Is this really the best you zoomers have got?
ReplyDeleteDear Flying Scotsman
ReplyDelete"This article reads like it was written by a child.Is this really the best you zoomers have got?"
Some time ago, I remarked back in 2012 that I listened to one of Sturgeon's pals read from a piece of paper, I said I thought I had stumbled into a 8 year old reading class, I assume that your dig is in someway referencing my remark of yesterday.
Finally my blog is written by me, there are no zoomers in the background, that is how the SNP operate.
George