Dear All
The Law Society of Scotland says the new Scotland Bill which
has come to pass via the Smith Commission has successfully “incorporated” the
terms of the devolution deal.
In truth, there was never any possibility that David Cameron
would renege on what some people called ‘the vow’.
Already, Nicola Sturgeon has decided to cry foul and complaint
the new powers fall short of what is needed.
And regardless if anything else comes to the Scottish
Parliament; her call will be always the same.
The Law Society of Scotland in the shape of its president,Alistair
Morris, says the legislation “reflects” the agreement struck by the parties.
Measures agreed include the transfer of “important areas of law policy” such as
welfare, income tax and some VAT revenues.
With Sturgeon doing her grudge, grievance and malcontent
routine, she yet again shows her startling lack of class and statesmanship. It
is also rather embarrassing for Nicola Sturgeon and her deputy, John Swinney
that such a body as the Law Society of Scotland is publicly speaking out
against them.
The SNP leadership put into motion publicly a narrative that
Scots had been betrayed because the Bill failed to match the “spirit or intent
of the Smith Agreement”.
We all know now, the reality is that the ‘Sein Fein’ SNP
actually wanted a Conservative Government, they had no intention of working
with Labour, and their entire campaign was to destroy the Scottish Labour
Party.
Although some of the Labour MPs had a good track record,
others didn’t, and that was one of the biggest single causes in Labour’s epic
defeat. If you don’t take care of your constituents then you can expect to see
anger grow, a tipping point then arises and the good get swept out with the bad.
It is doubtful some of those Labour MPs defeated will be
missed.
What has replaced them is some respects is pure trash, we
have already gotten a taste of that by the seating row and the happy clapping
episodes. When the new SNP MPs open their mouths, we will see how untalented
and inept they really are, student politics in a place such as Westminster will not play well.
The SNP like to cause trouble, this is mainly due to
ignorance; for example, they argued that the new legislation contained a series
of “vetoes” allowing UK ministers to block changes in areas related to welfare
payments and energy bills. This on the face of it seems like a legitimate
point, but we shouldn’t just blindly accept their word, the Scotland Office the
clauses highlighted by the SNP were only “practical arrangements to ensure the
transfer of new powers smoothly.”
See what I mean by a genuine lack of talent, grievance for
grievance, literally, it is like trying to deal with illiterates who don’t
understand Statehood or the mechanisms of such practices.
David Mundell, the Scottish Secretary has indicated that the
UK Government intends to fast-track the Bill; this means that voters will see
what deal the political parties which to put to the Scottish electorate. There
will come a point when the people of Scotland will realise that Nicola
Sturgeon isn’t doing anything to make their lives better.
Obviously the Conservatives are hoping that next May, they
will get to be the official opposition and replace Scottish Labour at Holyrood.
One thing which should be pointed from the Conservatives successful 2015
election is that in Scotland ,
Ruth Davidson failed her first major test of leadership.
She didn’t gain a single additional seat, this is important
to mention, and shouldn’t be glossed over.
Ruth Davidson can only have success by the process of the
Labour Party in Scotland
continual failure.
The new Scotland Bill will make Holyrood responsible for 60
per cent of Scottish spending and 40 per cent of taxation. I think the Conservatives
are being slightly hopeful that Sturgeon will raise taxes, what she will do is
cut burdens, what she will do is force councils to downsize jobs numbers.
We will also see at the same time, Nicola Sturgeon pushing
the living wage which she is currently doing at present as a smokescreen.
At First Minister’s Questions, Ms Sturgeon said:
“The UK Government, I think, had a very clear test today to
deliver a Bill which lived up in full, in spirit and in letter, to the Smith
Commission. The Bill has been published within the last hour or so and, from my
glance at it, I think it falls short in almost every area."
The key word here, is ‘glance’, do you remember what Nicola
Sturgeon said, ‘education got me where I am today’, you don’t glance at documents,
you read them fully, line by line. Incidentally, it wasn’t education that got
Nicola Sturgeon where she is today; it was screaming hate at SNP Conferences
about how everything is the fault of the English couched in the term
‘Westmintser’.
Deputy First Minister John Swinney said:
"Less than a fortnight ago, the Prime Minister came to Edinburgh and pledged to the people of Scotland to
deliver the Smith Agreement in full. Today, it's plain to see that promise has
been broken. Delivering the Smith Commission's recommendations was the minimum
the UK Government had to deliver."
My opinion of John Swinney has gone down since the Scottish
referendum.
What we will see in this term of the Westminster
parliament aside from the SNP making fools in the Chamber of the House of
Commons is the political landscape of the United Kingdom drastically
changing.
This will happen and the SNP will become irrelevant, matters
of substance will be set in motion while Nicola Sturgeon’s MPs just carp on the
sidelines.
Yours sincerely
George Laird
The Campaign for Human Rights at Glasgow
University
Scotland Office adviser Professor Adam Tomkins on the Scotland Bill, tells SNP to "put up or shut up"!
ReplyDeletehttps://notesfromnorthbritain.wordpress.com/2015/05/28/the-smith-commission-agreement-and-the-scotland-bill/
"If Scottish Ministers do not like the tax and spend decisions taken by the United Kingdom Government in Westminster, the Smith Commission Agreement — and now today's Bill — gives them the power to do something about it.
In short, they will be able to put our money where their mouths are.
They can fill what they perceive to be gaps in public spending on welfare and social security. They can create new benefits. They can top-up, for Scots, even those benefits which continue to be reserved to Westminster. And they have the tax powers to pay for it all.
This is why the Prime Minister said yesterday that it is finally time for the SNP to put up or shut up.
At last, we can move the argument on from nationalists' bleating that they don't have sufficient powers to a forensic examination of how they choose to use their powers."
Now lets see the fully costed proposals from the SNP about taxation and spending!
Stuart
The SNP were always going to claim not enough. This means they can shift the blame for their incompetence onto the Tories. Keeps the blinkered nats tossers topped up with just enough hate over the summer.
ReplyDeleteThey've now got what Smith proposed and as agreed, so now Kojak can get on with it and stop making excuses. If they can't produce, then good riddance to bad rubbish. SNP OUT !!
Stuart said it better than me though.
Lets all pray we get a good result. WATP.
Exactly!! so put up or shut up mouthpiece whinger Sturgeon, ohh, and I read today that she's off on a "jolly" to America. When will this leech start doing what she's paid for.
ReplyDeleteThe SNP rabble on about "positive campaigns". They are continually bitching and always, always blame Westminster for everything.
ReplyDeleteFunnily enough, Sturgeon has gone very, very quiet on the NHS. It's obviously sheer coincidence that the new hospital in Glasgow is organised chaos (I've been there recently so am speaking from first hand experience). Then there is the unbelievable case of a surgeon having to try and get a saw from B&Q!
My family, unfortunately, makes much use of the NHS. The staff are wonderful but they are hamstrung by decisions made at Holyrood. The only positive action taken by the SNP was keeping Monklands open (a family member has been attending clinics there for over 10 years now).
But they restrict cancer drugs available in England. Trying to see a physio or counsellor is nigh on impossible unless an emergency. The list goes on.
Now they have been given additional powers courtesy of the Smith commission, of which the SNP was part of. Now Sturgeon is bitching yet again.
I sense that now they have actually been given some real fiscal responsibility, they haven't a bloody clue what to do.
Slightly off topic, George, is it true that a certain heckler of a prominent ex-MO is facing charges relating to breach of the peace?